Cynthia Erivo to Headline JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR

After a hiatus that felt longer than the Lent season, musical theatre is returning to the Hollywood Bowl in Los Angeles. This summer production of JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR runs from 1 to 3 August 2025, marking the Bowl’s first major musical since pandemic lockdowns silenced its stage. If you needed a better reason to book a flight stateside (though the Aussie winter might already be enough motivation), look no further. With direction and choreography by Sergio Trujillo, plus Stephen Oremus guiding the musical side of things, expect a spectacular blend of dance, drama, and rock-opera flair.

The creative team is hardly stepping into uncharted territory. The Tim Rice–Andrew Lloyd Webber masterpiece first captivated audiences in the early 1970s, debuting as a concept album before exploding onto stages worldwide. What sets this Hollywood Bowl edition apart is less about reviving a classic and more about flipping it on its head. Cynthia Erivo, an Emmy, Grammy, and Tony Award winner (and thrice-nominated for an Oscar) will play Jesus Christ—one of the most recognisable male historical figures in Western culture. Let that sink in for a moment.

The Magnetism Of Cynthia Erivo

For anyone who’s heard Cynthia Erivo sing I’m Here from The Color Purple or her haunting version of Stand Up, it’s obvious the woman can elevate any stage she steps onto. Her vocals glide over multiple octaves with an emotional intensity that borders on the sublime. So purely from a musical perspective, it’s no surprise she was tapped for such a demanding role. Indeed, Gethsemane (I Only Want To Say)—that show-stopping aria depicting Jesus’ last night of doubt and surrender—requires a raw vocal and emotional verve. Who better than Erivo, whose range can punch through a heart?

Yet the casting decision goes beyond simple vocal prowess. Erivo’s presence is at once commanding and intimate, which suits the complexity of the character. JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR recounts the final weeks of Jesus’ life, but through the lens of Judas Iscariot’s disillusionment and heartbreak. Jesus, for all the attention he receives, can sometimes feel like a remote figure—less flawed than Judas, more prophetic than Mary Magdalene. Casting Erivo disrupts that detachment. Her mere presence makes us see Jesus in a fresh light: a divine figure with human vulnerabilities, crossing the boundary of gender norms to highlight a universal humanity. It’s thrilling and, for some, potentially provocative.

A Brief History Of Boundary-Pushing Castings

Those who argue that reimagining Jesus as female is shocking might want to flip through the archives of modern theatre. Casting across gender lines isn’t new. From Shakespearean times, where men portrayed all characters (including women), to contemporary musicals like Company in which the traditionally male “Bobby” became “Bobbie,” directors have frequently tried to reinvent roles. We’ve even seen an all-women production of Julius Caesar at the Donmar Warehouse in London, not to mention gender-bending turns in Macbeth. A 2019 report in The Stage indicated that 64% of surveyed UK theatres had experimented with non-traditional or gender-blind casting at least once in the prior five years.

However, Jesus is in a different league of iconic. Historical or religious figures often come freighted with centuries of devotion, theology, and cultural sensitivity. The question is whether audiences are ready for the potential dissonance—particularly those who view the character as sacrosanct. On the other side of the debate are fans who see this as a glorious opportunity to focus on the core message of love, sacrifice, and forgiveness, rather than fixating on the historical packaging. After all, the musical itself was never shy about modern touches. Its rock score, for instance, was considered radical when it first appeared.

Should We Care About Genderless Casting?

Let’s look at the bigger picture. Data from Live Performance Australia suggests that younger audiences are more open to these reinterpretations, with surveys showing a 35% jump in theatre attendance among 18- to 25-year-olds from 2017 to 2022. Producers know they can capture the curiosity of this demographic by experimenting with casting choices—especially if it delivers a fresh perspective on a well-known story.

For theatre purists, though, there’s a fear that the pendulum may swing too far. What if we lose sight of the historical context and nuance of certain narratives by flattening out crucial distinctions in culture, era, or identity? Is a female Jesus just a bold artistic statement, or does it risk trivialising a profoundly meaningful story for many viewers? Observers also point to potential confusion: if we make every role open to everyone, does that undermine the power of minority groups who’ve battled so long for representation in stories specifically about them?

The Show’s Past Versus Its Future

An intriguing footnote in this Hollywood Bowl production is that Erivo once participated in an all-female recording of JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR as Mary rather than Jesus. That earlier project was championed as a celebration of women’s voices in a rock-musical sphere often dominated by male leads. Now that she’s “graduated” to the title role, it raises the stakes on how we interpret the narrative. Will she portray Jesus as fiercely maternal, or will she keep the character’s biblical gravitas but with an added layer of modern femininity? Or perhaps we’ll see an androgynous approach that transcends both categories.

Another key figure worth acknowledging is Sergio Trujillo, a Tony Award-winning director and choreographer whose previous credits include JERSEY BOYS and ON YOUR FEET!. Trujillo is well known for infusing his productions with dynamic movement and a flair for the contemporary. With him at the helm, we might expect a visual and choreographic style that further subverts expectations—imagine a desert scene reinterpreted with modern dance, or a triumphant Hosanna brimming with fresh staging choices that have never been attempted before. Coupled with musical direction by Stephen Oremus, fans are anticipating a production that will lean heavily into luscious harmonies while keeping the rock edge unmistakably present.

Has Genderless Casting Of Historical Figures Gone Too Far?

The question looming over all of this is whether theatre has overstepped a boundary by giving historically male roles to female or non-binary performers. Some critics argue that reassigning genders can overshadow the original context or religious significance. Especially when the figure is as culturally loaded as Jesus Christ, a certain portion of the audience might see this as more stunt than statement.

But in a medium that thrives on innovation and re-examination, is there truly a point at which we declare “enough”? Theatre, at its most vibrant, tests limits and provokes conversation. Tim Rice and Andrew Lloyd Webber’s rock opera already did that half a century ago, painting biblical events in psychedelic 1970s colours. If there’s any show that can withstand another radical reinterpretation, it’s JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR—its rebellious spirit was baked into its creation.

Besides, a successful production doesn’t operate in a vacuum. If audiences flock to the Hollywood Bowl, if they find themselves moved or unsettled or enthralled by Cynthia Erivo’s portrayal, that response contributes to the cultural evolution of how we collectively see theatre, faith, and historical storytelling. And if it fails? Well, theatre has a knack for self-correction. Major flops and controversies become cautionary tales that guide future productions, ensuring we never stop learning or experimenting.

As a nine-year-old belting out I Don’t Know How To Love Him in the backyard, I wouldn’t have dreamt that one day a woman, let alone a star like Cynthia Erivo, would officially tackle the lead. Yet here we are, on the threshold of a production that dares to question whose voices we hear when we retell the world’s best-known stories. Perhaps that’s the magic of theatre: it reinvents, challenges, and stretches our perspectives in ways both thrilling and unsettling.

So, has genderless casting of historical figures gone too far? In my view, it’s gone just far enough to remind us that our cultural narratives are not static relics. They’re living, breathing stories that can adapt to new voices and fresh interpretations. Where some see controversy, I see a crucible for conversation. And if this JESUS CHRIST SUPERSTAR at the Hollywood Bowl sparks meaningful dialogue on art, faith, and representation, then, in the grand design of musical theatre, it might just be the closest thing to a miracle performance we’ll witness this season.

Photo Credit: DepositPhotos.com